Saw “American Hardcore” last night.
It brought me back a couple of years, to the days of my heavy infatuation with the commonly recognized hardcore greats, Black Flag in particular. I have very vivid memories of listening to the Nervous Breakdown ep on a portable record player in the park, in absolute awe. There were other bands, but it was mainly Black Flag that hit me. and they sure did hit me hard.
Of course, during that time in my life I wasn’t the happiest person and this is why, I think, after watching the movie:
Hardcore was devoid, almost, of any intillectual meaning. Its only value lay in the emotion behind it the music. Hardcore ideals were founded on anger and hatred (the two things I avoid like plague these days) and it seems like few of the hardcore “philosophers” were very intelligent.
From what I’ve read in interviews, listened to in lyrics, so forth, the idealogy of hardcore was mostly either way the hell off base or even shallower than the hippies. You get nowhere from hating and dehumanizing your adversaries, from glorifying adversity with the majority of humans. You watch this movie, look at Keith Morris sitting in front of his goddamn swimming pool saying “I hated my job, I hated my parents, I hated the cops, I hated school” and you think “It’s just a bunch of whining kids!”
Give me revolution summer any day. Although I’ve got a funny story about that: a friend of my dad’s who went to see the movie afterwords, was voicing his dissillusionment with Mackaye, saying he’d been to the dischord house and witnessed him giving the same damn tour of the basement (“come here, I want you to see something. This is where it all happened”) three times.
But if anyone’s got a right to be overly earnest and proud, it’s that guy.